(Log in to disable ads.)

I'm looking for a chord generator..
Something almost identical to this, but maybe someone knows something better?
http://jguitar.com/chord?root=d&tuning=4A%2C4E%2C5A%2C5D%2C5G%23%2C6C%23&chord=Major
A key feature is being able to tell it what I'm tuned in.. In my case it's: A E A D G C# and then generate desired chord shapes based on that.
(the pasted link should show you D major shapes in my tuning)

I'd like to use this as a composition tool by choosing a chord (eg minor 9th) and then generating all the chords that 'go' with it. Is that possible, or do I need to know more theory?

After 20 years+ of playing guitar I've never attempted to compose in this way. Maybe you guys have some input?
    What sort of theory level are you at now? Do you understand the basics of building triads (harmonizing) the major scale, as a starting point?
      Im at zero level I'd say. I know scales and some chords, but not composition theory.

      For example.. If I play this:


      I want to know what other chords could be played after that to compose a song. Nothing more, nothing less.

      I'm seeing talk of chord progression wheels? http://www.all-guitar-chords.com/circle-of-fifths.php
        xdoomx wrote: I'm looking for a chord generator..
        Something almost identical to this, but maybe someone knows something better?
        http://jguitar.com/chord?root=d&tuning=4A%2C4E%2C5A%2C5D%2C5G%23%2C6C%23&chord=Major
        A key feature is being able to tell it what I'm tuned in.. In my case it's: A E A D G C# and then generate desired chord shapes based on that.
        (the pasted link should show you D major shapes in my tuning)

        I'd like to use this as a composition tool by choosing a chord (eg minor 9th) and then generating all the chords that 'go' with it. Is that possible, or do I need to know more theory?

        After 20 years+ of playing guitar I've never attempted to compose in this way. Maybe you guys have some input?
        this is a very cool tool. if you don't mind, i'm gonna borrow it.

        shreddy's question is extremely pertinent to this discussion. scales, scale tones, chord tones; in theory, the principles are the same, in essence. but you will require at least a basic understanding of it if your composition is to really get off the ground. essentially, it works like this (and this is the very basics, the building blocks, as it were. this is probably dangerous, as over-simplification can often lead to confusion, so feel free to pick this apart if you need further clarification):

        starting with the major scale (the do-re-mi we all learned in nursery scale, sorry, school), and using the C major scale for simplicity's sake, you get the following notes:
        C D E F G A B (and back to) C. in other words, do - re - mi - fa - so - la - ti - (which will bring us back to) do.

        in a more generic sense, this is sometimes expressed as using roman numerals, but don't worry about this too much right now.

        what is more important than the notes themselves, is the intervals between them. if you apply the same interval formula, and start on any note, you will always end up with a major scale. (note: the same applies to chords. each chord structure has its own 'formula'. ever played an F major barre chord? slide the shape up two frets and you have a G major barre chord. same shape, different sound. same principle.)

        key to the formula:
        R: (root note, starting place for the scale. start on any note, apply the formula, and you're playing the scale.)
        W: (whole step, two frets on the guitar, two notes apart on the piano keyboard [including black keys].)
        H: (half step; one fret on the guitar, one note up/down [but generally speaking, up] on the piano keyboard.)

        the formula for the major scale looks like this:
        R W W H W W W (and then a half step back up to the root). C - D is one whole step. D - E again. E - F is a half step. F - G is a whole step. G - A is another whole step. the last whole step is A - B, and then B - C is a half step.

        so. enough with the boring (but necessary) stuff. how to put a song together in a key. we'll use the key of C major as a reference point because the key is the starting point. it will tell you what scale to use, which, in turn, unlocks the majority of the chords for you. right, we're in the key of C major, and we're using chords built off the C major scale. (that one up there with which we're far too familiar.) but how to build which chords?

        another formula (last one, i promise. but probably most important when it comes to chords):
        I ii iii IV V vi vii I

        this formula (i call it a formula - no idea what the correct term for it is) tells us, or me at any rate, what 'flavour' or character, each degree of the major scale has. you've probably seen something like this if you've ever seen the circle of fifths. is it major, or minor, basically. if the degree is uppercase, it's major. if it's lowercase, it's minor. (the vii'th degree is a special case when it comes to building chords off of it, but we'll get there.)

        so. let's build some chords. or, as shreddy more accurately put it - triads. as you can probably guess, or probably even know, a triad consists of three notes. let us commence with the first one.

        i can do this in my head, kind of have a visual piano keyboard and/or fretboard up there, depending, so pardon me if it takes a while to lay down here. we're working with the C major scale - or, more accurately, its notes and intervals. we want to build a chord off the first note, because it's the first note. the most common form of chord is a triad, or stacked thirds. check it out.

        C D E F G A B C could also be written as 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 (not a formula, more a kind of shorthand. your Cm11, for instance, took that counting all the way up to 11. which is the same note as the 4, only an octave higher, generally speaking. but, it can be used another way. we'll see as we build our triad.) check it out.

        C D E F G A B C = 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1, and we're looking for stacked thirds. so what note is the first third?

        C D E F G A B C. so the first two notes of our triad are C and E. but we need another third up from E, because we're stacking another third on top of the first two notes. hmm... what's the third up from E in the key of C?

        C D E F G A B C. cool. three notes, stuck on top of each other, give us our first triad in C. C E G. if you've been playing for any amount of time, this is probably among of the first chords you learned - C major.

        if you apply the same principle to the second degree of the major scale - D - you'll end up with the same result - a triad that you recognise as a chord you have used a lot more than a dozen times. i'm not gonna do the job, i'm pretty sure you get the gist of it by now.

        adding colour to your compositional repertoire comes with time, practice of these principles, and extending your chords beyond the triads. you can do this on paper - write out the octave a few times, three or so, end to end, and see how many different chord types you can make up and identify, using both naturals as well as sharps and flats. but suspended 2nds, 4ths, that's where to start - play a different kind of 'triad' by adding the 2nd or 4th without the third, and then 'resolve' to the third. add in 7#9ths - a favourite trick of hendrix, it almost became a signature of his sound. go above and beyond mere triads, stretch all over the fretboard for new and interesting places to play chords. have fun.

        speaking of which, the last trick is knowing your fretboard backward. (and i should be the last one to talk!) if you know the make up of the chords, moving the notes around the fretboard should be a breeze.

        i don't mean to condescend, and i apologise if i have. it's just these theory building blocks are essential to getting things started. i also apologise to those theory gurus who will immediately realise that i have made countless errors of terminology. i hope and trust that i have at least got the facts correct.

        i hope i haven't done too much damage...
        dh
          Yoh! Post of the year! I'm going to bookmark this. I really appreciate your response!!

          I'd love for you to take a look at 'Harmony Navigator' and let me know what you think? (this sounds spammy but I promise it's not - I have no affiliation)
          Harmony Navigator

          It was a bit overwhelming at first but this vid explained it http://www.cognitone.com/video/hn2/HN2Intro1/en/HN2Intro1-desktop.m4v

          It seems to display all the chords that 'fit' (after choosing a root note and major/minor) in this way:

            xdoomx wrote: Yoh! Post of the year! I'm going to bookmark this. I really appreciate your response!!

            I'd love for you to take a look at 'Harmony Navigator' and let me know what you think? (this sounds spammy but I promise it's not - I have no affiliation)
            Harmony Navigator

            It was a bit overwhelming at first but this vid explained it http://www.cognitone.com/video/hn2/HN2Intro1/en/HN2Intro1-desktop.m4v

            It seems to display all the chords that 'fit' (after choosing a root note and major/minor) in this way:
            no prob. so this thing looks pretty neat. but my appraisal of it would be the same as that of my appraisal of games like rocksmith - you're gonna have fun but not really learn much. it's a short cut. if you want to 'write' cool-sounding chord progressions, use it - i don't think anyone will think any less of you. i certainly wouldn't.

            if you put together these cool-sounding progressions using harmony navigator, and then reverse-engineer them to the point where, eventually, you start figuring out for yourself why certain chords work well after other chords, why all these chords work well in the context of a C minor scale, why you can use these different chords - which essentially use notes not found in the C minor scale - work, then you'll be a man, my son. musically speaking, of course.

            as i said, the stuff above is the very, very basic basics. it's the starting point. use it as such. dissect. every chord you play is made up of notes, those notes relate to each other within a key. understand those relationships, and you will move far faster, further, and higher.

            go! play! live! oh wait, sorry. wrong forum...
            dh
              Excellent. Thank you so much!! You have inspired me!
                9 days later
                "all guitar chords" may be the most easy from all these. If you're a beginner, than I would suggest you not learning 9, 11 and 15 degree chords. Learn simple ones (basic or open string) and 7th chords first to understand how they are built!
                  I'm mainly interested in the sad/sombre/depressing chords.. I've learned that these will obviously be minor... but also 7ths, 11s as well as Lydian and Phrygian. Can anyone confirm this?
                    hmm. so, you really should get yourself a good theory teacher - but someone who can take you through the basics first, and build up from there. (not being funny - just calling it as i see it.)

                    but, to answer at least in part, your questions...

                    - 'sad sounding' chords would, yes, be minor chords. them triads we talked about? build the triads off the second, third, and sixth degree of the C major scale, and you will get the three minor chords you can use in the key of C major - use the same basic principles i outlined. the triad built off the seventh degree is a diminished chord, a somewhat different beast for those with a better understanding of the concept than i to tackle.

                    - 7ths, 11ths, etc, these are notes added to a chord for additional 'flavour'. a 7th (sometimes - usually - referred to as a dominant 7th chord, when added to a major triad) won't necessarily make a chord sound 'sad', more likely add what i call a 'solidly unresolved' flavour to the chord. by that i mean it feels that your next chord should probably be the root chord of the key. it doesn't mean it has to be - and if it isn't, it adds some lekker tension to your progression - but it feels like it should a lot of the time. try this progression for size, four beats per chord: C, Am, F, G7. doesn't it feel like the next chord should be C?

                    - lydian, phrygian. these aren't chords, they are the names of modes. modes are interesting wee beasties, and i must admit to a general lack of knowledge on the subject. suffice to say they have their place, and each of the seven modes can be used to elicit a specific feeling, but i would say the lydian mode would be a 'happy' mode, and the phrygian possibly sad. the lydian mode is 'built off' the fourth degree of the major scale (or ionian mode), while the phrygian is 'built off' the third. and i use many of these terms loosely. modes are relatively advanced theory space to be playing in without a good grounding, so perhaps best to leave them alone until the foundations are dug and, oh, at least the framework of the studio is built?

                    good luck
                    dh
                      domhatch wrote: hmm. so, you really should get yourself a good theory teacher - but someone who can take you through the basics first, and build up from there. (not being funny - just calling it as i see it.)

                      but, to answer at least in part, your questions...

                      - 'sad sounding' chords would, yes, be minor chords. them triads we talked about? build the triads off the second, third, and sixth degree of the C major scale, and you will get the three minor chords you can use in the key of C major - use the same basic principles i outlined. the triad built off the seventh degree is a diminished chord, a somewhat different beast for those with a better understanding of the concept than i to tackle.

                      - 7ths, 11ths, etc, these are notes added to a chord for additional 'flavour'. a 7th (sometimes - usually - referred to as a dominant 7th chord, when added to a major triad) won't necessarily make a chord sound 'sad', more likely add what i call a 'solidly unresolved' flavour to the chord. by that i mean it feels that your next chord should probably be the root chord of the key. it doesn't mean it has to be - and if it isn't, it adds some lekker tension to your progression - but it feels like it should a lot of the time. try this progression for size, four beats per chord: C, Am, F, G7. doesn't it feel like the next chord should be C?

                      - lydian, phrygian. these aren't chords, they are the names of modes. modes are interesting wee beasties, and i must admit to a general lack of knowledge on the subject. suffice to say they have their place, and each of the seven modes can be used to elicit a specific feeling, but i would say the lydian mode would be a 'happy' mode, and the phrygian possibly sad. the lydian mode is 'built off' the fourth degree of the major scale (or ionian mode), while the phrygian is 'built off' the third. and i use many of these terms loosely. modes are relatively advanced theory space to be playing in without a good grounding, so perhaps best to leave them alone until the foundations are dug and, oh, at least the framework of the studio is built?

                      good luck
                      dh
                      Just to add in a few corrections Dom:

                      - Triads are built using the 1st, 3rd and 5th (not 6th) degree of the major scale. You had it right earlier on when you went through the "stacking thirds" concept.

                      - The diminished chord is not built off the seventh, it is just another kind of triad. Following on from your earlier "stacking thirds" stuff:

                      > The interval we call a third can be either a minor third (3 semi-tones) or a major third (4 semi-tones)
                      > This gives 4 ways of stacking thirds to get the 4 different triad types:
                      - Major 3rd + Minor 3rd = Major triad = 1 3 5
                      - Minor 3rd + Major 3rd = Minor triad = 1 b3 5
                      - Major 3rd + Major 3rd = Augmented triad = 1 3 #5
                      - Minor 3rd + Minor 3rd = Diminished triad = 1 b3 b5

                      So a diminished chord is just a chord made from two minor 3rd intervals stacked on the root note.



                      - Regarding 7th chords: the interval that will create the major/minor "feel" of the chord is still going to be the very first third that got stacked on the root, as discussed above. So, adding a 7th to a major chord will still sound like a major chord, just with the added tension or flavour you've described. A dominant 7th chord has the same formula as a major triad, just with a flat seventh (b7) added, so the full formula is 1 3 5 b7. If you added the seventh without flattening it, you get 1 3 5 7 which is a major seventh chord. You are correct about a dominant chord having a strong pull to the I chord, but remember that the dominant 7th is only one of the 10 different types of 7th chords you could construct.



                      @xdoomx
                      It's important to note that all Western music theory starts with the major scale. When talking about the 3 minor scales (natural/relative, harmonic and melodic minor) those discussions all happen relative to how the major scale works, and how chords are built using the major scale. If you really want to understand how to use the sad, depression progressions for yourself, you need to start with the major scale and the chords built from it (which is what Don took you through) and then you're in a solid position to move into minor progressions.

                      The modes you mentioned are also major scale modes, so to understand how they work you need to understand how the major scale is used as the basis of all the other stuff.

                      It's not that hard, or even that time consuming. Justin Sandercoe (www.justinguitar.com) has some great videos explaining this stuff, and there is plenty of stuff on the web otherwise.
                        ShreddySmurf wrote: Just to add in a few corrections Dom:

                        - Triads are built using the 1st, 3rd and 5th (not 6th) degree of the major scale. You had it right earlier on when you went through the "stacking thirds" concept.
                        oops. see, this is why i should just leave this to those more qualified. what i was trying to convey is much better explained in your next bit:
                        - The diminished chord is not built off the seventh, it is just another kind of triad. Following on from your earlier "stacking thirds" stuff:

                        > The interval we call a third can be either a minor third (3 semi-tones) or a major third (4 semi-tones)
                        > This gives 4 ways of stacking thirds to get the 4 different triad types:
                        - Major 3rd + Minor 3rd = Major triad = 1 3 5
                        - Minor 3rd + Major 3rd = Minor triad = 1 b3 5
                        - Major 3rd + Major 3rd = Augmented triad = 1 3 #5
                        - Minor 3rd + Minor 3rd = Diminished triad = 1 b3 b5

                        So a diminished chord is just a chord made from two minor 3rd intervals stacked on the root note.
                        - Regarding 7th chords: the interval that will create the major/minor "feel" of the chord is still going to be the very first third that got stacked on the root, as discussed above. So, adding a 7th to a major chord will still sound like a major chord, just with the added tension or flavour you've described. A dominant 7th chord has the same formula as a major triad, just with a flat seventh (b7) added, so the full formula is 1 3 5 b7. If you added the seventh without flattening it, you get 1 3 5 7 which is a major seventh chord. You are correct about a dominant chord having a strong pull to the I chord, but remember that the dominant 7th is only one of the 10 different types of 7th chords you could construct.
                        awesome, got this now - gonna have a look at it in more detail for mine own edification.

                        thanks shreddy, two birds, one stone. you're well rockin.
                        dh
                          Write a Reply...