Spyke wrote:
Bob Dubery wrote:
U2, the Stones, Celine Dion... all performed in SA, still going strong. Must be more.
I feel otherwise to this. Only recently heard something new from U2 and it really isn't getting the rave reviews one would think from a band of their stature. Their latest sounds like they're trying too hard to reinvent themselves.
Celine - she too is just riding a wave of past success - minimal new material. SA was everything but a boost for her career.
Stones, can't comment there.
U2 have just announced a major tour with all sorts of "never been seen before" features. They're still a viable act, and whilst they're not going to sell the new album in "Joshua Tree" numbers, I doubt they're going to be losing much on the album or on the tour.
Most acts have a peak in their careers anyway. Not all U2 albums sold or will sell like the Joshua Tree. Led Zeppelin had some massive hit albums, but then things started tailing off. Elton John still tours and gives live shows, but his platinum album days are behind him.
What killed Celine Dion's career I think (albeit making her a lot of money in the process) was a long residency in Las Vegas. She was certainly very happening when she came to SA.
I don't think that SA is the kiss of death to visiting acts. It may be that for the acts that play in soccer stadiums and the like that they are, shall we say, seeking to diversify. I think there is a pattern of acts making it big with sales and concert tickets in the UK and USA and then looking to other markets - Asia, South America etc. So at that point these big acts might include SA on a schedule, but I think that's a function of their changed circumstances rather than touring SA putting the kibosh on them.
For many years now the Stones concert ticket sales have been out of relation to their album sales. I would think that U2 are in a similar state now.
The problem, I think, is that we don't have well developed circuits of smaller venues that bands can play - and that we're a long way from the UK and the USA. In the UK if you don't want to go see whatever dinosaur is playing that 02 Dome that weekend you have plenty of choices - many of them bands that are still rising and playing in smaller venues, but something a bit better and perhaps more appealing than a pub. Do we have such options here?