Squonk wrote:
There were Morgans, Breedloves , Taylors, Gibsons, a lone Takamine, Martins, Yamahas, Ibanez
A good venue to see and hear all these wonderful instruments.
What I noticed -
The Morgan sounded top class, good balance between bass and treble strings, good for fingerpicking(Had the truest acoustic sound on the night)
Breedlove - lovely rich sound (LR Baggs Anthem, I was told) and Mike Burgers playing style(full of textures and colour and swells) made this instrument a desirable thing.
The Taylor, Gibson and Martin sounded if anything just below average, I am still waiting to hear good Taylor tone in a live setting.
IMO the recent Taylors with factory fit electronics don't cut the mustard.
Paul Hohns pops up at TJs from time to time and he has an older Taylor that always sounds good - plugged in or not.
Squonk, your Takamine sounds pretty good plugged in. Also Fingerpicker commented that he didn't have to do much to get a good sound out of your Taka - it's "plug and play".
Mike Burger is a good friend of mine and I know that Breedlove well. It's a fab guitar. As you note, it had a Mike Burger attached to it. This is a good thing. Mike has a great touch on an acoustic guitar and always makes a guitar sound good. I have never heard my Morgan sing like it does when Mike plays it.
Fingerpicker who does the sound does a great job, so it wasn't the case of the dodgy sound man ? There were no effects involved, so I am wandering if the pickups/preamps were not up to scratch? I know Bob's Morgan has an LR Baggs, maybe this is the difference!
One thing I noticed is that you need to have a decent soundhole pickup! The Yamaha sounded like pea soup(green and murky).
Take pity on Fingerpicker. That's not an easy sound job. Short sets. Lots of them. Minimal setup time. All those different guitars and different pickups - some with lots of grunt and some with little. Some guys want to plug in, some want to be miced up.
The guys who got their early and did a soundcheck got better sound. But at an evening such as this where people just walk in and ask to play there is no way to soundcheck everybody.