please help with this odd request

crazymunki

Hi dudes,

please tell me which of these two song you like better, ignore production value...they are both demos with the same verse... me and the band are disagreeing and i decided to put it out there, and let the people decide

1.wma
http://www.box.net/shared/vns83z5f7o

2.wma
http://www.box.net/shared/fzzigftg2z

AlanRatcliffe

Number two is far better for the simple reason that the delay in #1 detracts from the song.

inflames

First song don't want to open up. The second song is pretty cool!

crazymunki

thx guys... the first song was bounced wrong, blonde moment... re-upped it... so you can have a proper listen

inflames

Thanks, both work now ?

Still prefer the second one!

crazymunki

cool ? and thx for the input!!!

PeteM

The 2nd one.

AlanRatcliffe

Generally the second, but I prefer the fatter drum tones in the first.

G

I vote number 2

crazymunki

ok, i hear you alan, but you gotta ignore instrumentation and jsut listen to the songs... of cos 2 sounds better, but is it a more appealing song??

thats what i need to know... sorry, not what i need to know, what i need to prove to the band ?

AlanRatcliffe

Still number two...

MIKA-the-better-one

Is your band evolver???

MIKA-the-better-one

oh but yeh the 2nd one is better

crazymunki

Lol MiKA ... no... i cant say...

inflames

but I prefer the fatter drum tones in the first

Alan, I agree with this.

crazymunki, is this a issue with the mix? If you can use the drum track on the first take with the 2'nd song you have a hit in my ears ?

crazymunki

THE ISSUE IS THE CHORUS... BASICALLY WHICH CHORUS MAKES THE SONG A BETTER SONG...

Jack-Flash-Jr

crazymunki wrote: THE ISSUE IS THE CHORUS... BASICALLY WHICH CHORUS MAKES THE SONG A BETTER SONG...

No need to shout ?
The second CHORUS is a better chorus and therefore makes the song a better song IMHO.