singemonkey wrote
I had a real face-palm realisation about my last "performance" that I was agonising about so much in this thread. The song that messed me up the most, that I felt like I'm really comfortable playing? Well, I sat down with a metronome. Before I switched it on, I set the tempo with my vocal and adjusted the metronome to match.
It was way too fast. There's no way, I could play that fast. I had to keep racking it back until I got to the point I could play it through. Now the song starts with the harmony vocals unaccompanied. Bit of pressure on the night and, hey presto! Trying to play it much faster than I could possibly manage.
I've struggled with this and suspect that I still do on some numbers. What the answer is I'm not sure, but I think being aware of it helps.
One of the first songs I ever played in front of an audience (might even be THE first) was an old Richard Thompson song "The Old Changing Way". I was getting more or less happy with what I was practicing, but I was not sure about an intro so I listened to the original. It was like hearing the thing in slow motion. So I played it to a stop watch. Handily under 2 minutes. I was going to get a 15 minute slot at TJs so I played my whole planned set to the stop watch. It came in at about 8 minutes! So I played it again this time including lots of
bollocks patter in between songs. Still under time.
I had to work hard at slowing things down. Of course when I did that the songs got easier and I made less mistakes.
I think I may have still rushed it on the night, but at least I'm aware of the problem now and can try to prepare better. Getting a rough idea of the tempo and tapping that out with my foot helps some - I think if you can hear the beat externally (even if only softly) then that gives you a better idea of what tempo you're about to play at and you have a shot at altering the tempo.
So anyhoo... you're not alone, and I suspect this is a not uncommon problem. It may be more easily dealt with in a band, especially if there's a couple of experienced players involved. I think it's trickier for solo performers.
I also think that with experience you develop a better instinct for such things.