(Log in to disable ads.)

  • Off-Topic
  • Kickstarter/Ingiegogo products...are they mostly silly?

I've been trawling youtube and checking out the latest crop of inventions/products.

Overall, I'm inspired - there's a lot of passion out there and people are making things happen.

But...I can't help feeling there's fair number of products that are either "taking the piss" or really havn't been thought out (passion > common sense)? Yeah, I'm a touch cynical.

Out of the +/-50 products I've seen recently the silliest two have to be :

1. Noke padlock : Unlocks via bluetooth key on your smartphone. It needs a battery that (maybe) lasts one year. The battery drains rapidly in temperatures < 0C and from the user reviews it doesn't survive well outdoors - SA's climate would kill these things. DId I mention it's $70...the mind boggles.

2. Genican - it's a tool that monitors your trash to generate a shopping list. Umm. No. Just no. Scanning your trash? Whatever next... :?

On the bright side, there are some winners!

1. Kraftwerk power bank - uses propane to charge your usb devices. Genius! Before you dismiss this...remember load shedding. I'd spend $70 on this.

2. Education toys : Particularly ones teaching basic programming skills. mCookie caught my eye, compatible with lego, arduino based microcontroller. There's quite a few arduino based toys, really clever!

3. Modduo : The only musical win on my list so far - a stompbox that you can load plugin's onto and use live. This one I've had my eye on for a looong time. It's at Namm this year, so here's hoping I see one in my hands sometime

And the laugh has to the "Coolest" cooler box. 62k backers = > $13 Million pledged. Blew my mind. The is one idea that wouldn't have make it out the sharktank...and it's ridiculously popular. ???

Whats are your winners/loser in the indie products world?.
    I've had some awesome and ...less awesome Kickstarter experiences.

    Wins include:
    Zombies...Run! - This running app weaves an audio play in with your playlist, which is a well-written post-apocalyptic survival story. For extra motivation, you occasionally need to pick up your speed as the zombies get too close
    Naturebytes - a camera trap based on a Raspberry Pi- I've taken photos of all sorts of interesting creatures in the garden. This one shipped six months late, but I was kept up to speed with the delays the whole time.

    I've also backed simple, digital-only projects fora couple of dollars- that way, if they never deliver, no great loss. Good ones included a project to refurbish Neil Armstrong's moon gloves and a digital download of the new Tree63 album.

    The general rule is that if they have a track record of delivering products, whether on Kickstarter or elsewhere, and a working prototype, you can be confident of getting something, but the thing to remember is that this is a funding site for projects, not a group-buying discount website- it is _possible_ to fund a project that fails, delivers late or has to reduce it's scope drastically
      Write a Reply...