Chad Adam Browne wrote:
This I can't agree with you on, Prog Rock and Prog Metal are my favourite genres because there's just no limit on what is and isn't allowed. Porcupine Tree is every bit as prog as Riverside, or at least in my opinion they are because they sound nothing alike. Most prog bands don't, it was a musical mindset started by King Crimson so long ago, one of breaking rules and boundaries while still trying to create music that was melodic, intelligent and beautiful ?
I agree Chad
I think what I was trying to say about Porcupine Tree (dont get me wrong I think they are a great band) is that they are definately in this genre but with me being an old prog rocker, I was brought up on King Crimson, Emerson, Lake and Palmer, Genesis, Yes, Greenslade, van der Graaf Generator etc
I was possibly measuring PT with the wrong stick ? After hearing Riverside, I think they are possibly more progressive and truer to the Prog Rock genre that I am used to! Riverside have that creative edge that possibly extends to the dark side a bit more than PT, if that's possible. I dont find much classical influence in PT!
I have heard good things about Animals as Leaders, must give them a bash
Strange enough on the Opeth Album I have, 'Deliverance', they do a 'Genesis' cover "For absent friends" that is quite an interesting interpretation of the original. And when I say 'Genesis', I dont mean the 'Earth, Wind and Fire' clone band that Phil Collins destroyed in the 80's ?
Good Stuff